Following the death of their father, a brother and sister are sent to live with a foster mother, only to learn that she is hiding a terrifying secret.
The Philippou brothers' follow-up to Talk to Me earns strong marks for Sally Hawkins' unsettling lead performance and a confident command of pacing and tension, though a persistent debate runs through the reviews: does its emotional ambition actually land, or do the grotesque visuals crowd out genuine feeling? Most critics place it just below Talk to Me, citing a looser narrative logic, but few dispute that it announces the brothers as a serious horror force.
“more logically muddled than its predecessor”
Jeanette Catsoulis·New York Times
“superior grasp of pacing and catch-release tension”
David Fear·Rolling Stone
“it's hard to balance really effective emotionality with the type of vicious storytelling the Philippous appear to be interested in”
Sammie Purcell·Rough Draft Atlanta
“perhaps more chilling—if slightly less focused—than their breakout feature debut”
Monica Castillo·RogerEbert.com
Horror, Mystery
Following the death of their father, a brother and sister are sent to live with a foster mother, only to learn that she is hiding a terrifying secret.
The Philippou brothers' follow-up to Talk to Me earns strong marks for Sally Hawkins' unsettling lead performance and a confident command of pacing and tension, though a persistent debate runs through the reviews: does its emotional ambition actually land, or do the grotesque visuals crowd out genuine feeling? Most critics place it just below Talk to Me, citing a looser narrative logic, but few dispute that it announces the brothers as a serious horror force.
“more logically muddled than its predecessor”
Jeanette Catsoulis·New York Times
“superior grasp of pacing and catch-release tension”
David Fear·Rolling Stone
“it's hard to balance really effective emotionality with the type of vicious storytelling the Philippous appear to be interested in”
Sammie Purcell·Rough Draft Atlanta
“perhaps more chilling—if slightly less focused—than their breakout feature debut”
Monica Castillo·RogerEbert.com
Horror, Mystery