A struggling salesman takes custody of his son as he's poised to begin a life-changing professional career.
Critics were broadly split not on Will Smith — whose performance drew near-universal admiration — but on the film around him, which many found earnest to a fault and politically convenient in its portrait of poverty as a problem solved by individual grit. The real fault line was whether Smith's warmth was enough to redeem a story critics variously called formulaic, slight, and heavy-handed with coincidence and sentiment.
“The great surprise of the picture is that it's not corny ... The beauty of the film is its honesty. In its outlines, it's nothing like the usual success story depicted on-screen, in which, after a reasonable interval of disappointment, success arrives wrapped in a ribbon and a bow.”
Mick LaSalle·San Francisco Chronicle
“the film lays so many obstacles and solutions before its resilient hero that the volume of sentimentality and coincidence makes it feel suspect ... Neither Conrad's script nor Muccino's redundant direction shows [what] lifted the real-life Chris above better educated and more experienced candidates, but it comes through in the earnest performances of the two Smiths.”
Steve Persall·St. Petersburg Times
Biography, Drama
A struggling salesman takes custody of his son as he's poised to begin a life-changing professional career.
Critics were broadly split not on Will Smith — whose performance drew near-universal admiration — but on the film around him, which many found earnest to a fault and politically convenient in its portrait of poverty as a problem solved by individual grit. The real fault line was whether Smith's warmth was enough to redeem a story critics variously called formulaic, slight, and heavy-handed with coincidence and sentiment.
“The great surprise of the picture is that it's not corny ... The beauty of the film is its honesty. In its outlines, it's nothing like the usual success story depicted on-screen, in which, after a reasonable interval of disappointment, success arrives wrapped in a ribbon and a bow.”
Mick LaSalle·San Francisco Chronicle
“the film lays so many obstacles and solutions before its resilient hero that the volume of sentimentality and coincidence makes it feel suspect ... Neither Conrad's script nor Muccino's redundant direction shows [what] lifted the real-life Chris above better educated and more experienced candidates, but it comes through in the earnest performances of the two Smiths.”
Steve Persall·St. Petersburg Times
Biography, Drama