After an abrupt and violent encounter with a French warship inflicts severe damage upon his ship, a captain of the British Royal Navy begins a chase over two oceans to capture or destroy the enemy, though he must weigh his commitment to duty and ferocious pursuit of glory against the safety of his devoted crew, including the ship's thoughtful surgeon, his best friend.
Peter Weir's seafaring epic earned strong critical approval for its immersive period detail and rousing action sequences, but divided opinion on how faithfully — and how fully — it translated Patrick O'Brian's novels. The central tension between Crowe's captain and Paul Bettany's doctor drew particular scrutiny: some found their friendship the emotional core of the film, while others felt their dynamic was too neatly schematic and that the film fatally stripped away the doctor's complexity.
“it achieves the epic without losing sight of the human”
Roger Ebert·Chicago Sun-Times
“Any cinematic adaptation of O'Brian must stand or fall by its success in representing this figure [Dr. Stephen Maturin]. On this the film doesn't even fall, let alone stand. It skips the whole project.”
Christopher Hitchens·Slate
“Weir is less surefooted as a screenwriter. Having not read any of O'Brian's novels, I can't say if the fault is in Weir's adaptation or in the source material, but halfway into Master and Commander the friendship of the captain and the doctor begins to seem schematic, as if all the positive traits that an individual could have were divided equally between these two guys, just so they can argue.”
Mick LaSalle·San Francisco Chronicle
Action, Adventure, Drama
After an abrupt and violent encounter with a French warship inflicts severe damage upon his ship, a captain of the British Royal Navy begins a chase over two oceans to capture or destroy the enemy, though he must weigh his commitment to duty and ferocious pursuit of glory against the safety of his devoted crew, including the ship's thoughtful surgeon, his best friend.
Peter Weir's seafaring epic earned strong critical approval for its immersive period detail and rousing action sequences, but divided opinion on how faithfully — and how fully — it translated Patrick O'Brian's novels. The central tension between Crowe's captain and Paul Bettany's doctor drew particular scrutiny: some found their friendship the emotional core of the film, while others felt their dynamic was too neatly schematic and that the film fatally stripped away the doctor's complexity.
“it achieves the epic without losing sight of the human”
Roger Ebert·Chicago Sun-Times
“Any cinematic adaptation of O'Brian must stand or fall by its success in representing this figure [Dr. Stephen Maturin]. On this the film doesn't even fall, let alone stand. It skips the whole project.”
Christopher Hitchens·Slate
“Weir is less surefooted as a screenwriter. Having not read any of O'Brian's novels, I can't say if the fault is in Weir's adaptation or in the source material, but halfway into Master and Commander the friendship of the captain and the doctor begins to seem schematic, as if all the positive traits that an individual could have were divided equally between these two guys, just so they can argue.”
Mick LaSalle·San Francisco Chronicle
Action, Adventure, Drama